Madden, David O. Russell’s biopic starring Nicolas Cage as legendary NFL coach and broadcaster John Madden, drew its first wave of reviews on Tuesday, November 17, and critics are far from united. The Amazon MGM Studios film debuts on Prime Video on Wednesday, November 18.
What We Know
The early verdicts range from warm to harsh. The Associated Press gave the film 1.5 out of 4 stars, with critic Jake Coyle describing it as a sincere but scattered project that never settles on a tone, swinging between near-parody and earnest family drama. He was not convinced by Cage’s take on Madden’s famous voice, though he enjoyed Kathryn Hahn’s scenes and a late comic moment from John Mulaney. His conclusion: the movie “needed a game plan.”
TheWrap’s William Bibbiani landed in a similar place from a different angle. He found the film pleasant and Cage charming, but said it is more interested in celebrating Madden than in dramatizing his life, with little conflict to push the story forward. In his view, Christian Bale’s turn as Raiders owner Al Davis is the most interesting performance on screen. Consequence and Screen Daily were also critical, with both headlines comparing the film to a fumble.
Screen Rant offered the warmest notice, scoring it 6 out of 10. Reviewer Matthew Rudoy praised the transformations of both Cage and Bale and called their friendship the emotional core of the film. He felt the first half, built around Madden’s years coaching the Oakland Raiders, is funny and engaging, while the second half, focused on the creation of the video game, loses some momentum.
Background
John Madden coached the Oakland Raiders to a Super Bowl victory in January 1977, then became one of the most recognizable voices in American sports broadcasting before lending his name to EA’s Madden NFL video game franchise. He died in December 2021 at age 85. According to TheWrap, the film opens in the mid-1970s with Madden already leading the Raiders and follows him through his Super Bowl win, his exit from coaching and his second career in the booth and in gaming.
Russell co-wrote the script with Cambron Clark. The cast also includes Kathryn Hahn as Madden’s wife, Virginia, Sienna Miller as Carol Davis, and John Mulaney as EA founder Trip Hawkins, with comedian Shane Gillis in a supporting part. The AP review notes cameos from Snoop Dogg and former NFL running back Marshawn Lynch. Mulaney’s casting comes in a busy month for the comedian, who recently hosted Saturday Night Live for the seventh time.
Cage was cast in the title role in 2024, and filming began in Atlanta in April 2025. The movie runs 110 minutes and is rated R for language.
What’s Next
Viewers can judge for themselves when Madden starts streaming on Prime Video on November 18, 2026, just ahead of Thanksgiving week, when NFL viewing traditionally peaks in the United States. With reviews this split, word of mouth from football fans may matter more than the critics’ scorecards. For Cage, the role marks another high-profile swing in a career built on bold, unpredictable choices.
Sources
- Associated Press – Movie Review: ‘Madden’
- TheWrap – Madden review
- Screen Rant – Madden review
- Consequence – Madden review
- Screen Daily – Madden review
