The first wave of critics to see The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth came out of its Los Angeles premiere on Monday night, November 16, largely won over by Brad Pitt’s return as the laid-back stuntman. Directed by David Fincher from a script by Quentin Tarantino, the Netflix sequel to Once Upon a Time in Hollywood hits IMAX screens on November 25 before streaming on December 23.
What We Know
Social media reactions began landing on Tuesday, November 17, and the tone was overwhelmingly upbeat. Several critics reached for the same phrase: a “hangout movie,” the kind of film that is as much about spending time with its characters as it is about plot.
Variety’s awards editor Clayton Davis described it as a wild and very funny ride and argued that Pitt delivers his best work in the role since the 2019 original. He also singled out Elizabeth Debicki, and said Scott Caan and Peter Weller deserved even more screen time. TheWrap’s Drew Taylor was among the most enthusiastic, calling the film an “absolute triumph” and comparing the Tarantino-Fincher pairing to peanut butter and chocolate. Critic Simon Thompson framed it as a love letter to Los Angeles with a third act that really takes off, while io9’s Germain Lussier went as far as naming it his favorite movie of the year.
Not everyone was fully sold. Longtime critic Todd Gilchrist said he enjoyed it but wanted a second viewing before deciding whether the two filmmakers’ very different styles truly mesh, and Awards Watch’s Erik Anderson found it tonally uneven despite some fun set pieces. These are first impressions shared after a screening, not full reviews, so the broader critical picture will become clearer once formal reviews are published.
Background
The film picks up in 1977, eight years after the events of Once Upon a Time in Hollywood. Cliff now works as a studio fixer and finds himself in over his head while handling problems for a popular movie star. Alongside Brad Pitt, the cast includes Elizabeth Debicki, Scott Caan, Yahya Abdul-Mateen II, Carla Gugino and Peter Weller. Leonardo DiCaprio and Margot Robbie, who starred in the first film, are not part of the sequel.
The project is an unusual handoff. Tarantino wrote the screenplay but chose not to direct it, passing it to Fincher, the filmmaker behind Se7en, Fight Club and The Social Network. According to Variety, Fincher told Empire that Tarantino’s first draft ran 230 pages and that he trimmed about 60 of them.
The stakes are high because the original was a major hit. Released by Sony in 2019, Once Upon a Time in Hollywood earned around $410 million worldwide, picked up 10 Oscar nominations and won Pitt the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor. The film also featured Margaret Qualley in a memorable supporting role.
Reactions
Beyond the critics already mentioned, Critics Choice member Ricky Válero called the movie a “banger” and placed it among the best releases of the year, while critic Zach Pope praised the mix of Tarantino’s chaos, Fincher’s precision and Pitt’s charisma. Variety’s Jazz Tangcay named Debicki the film’s standout. With praise this concentrated on Pitt’s performance, some writers have already started floating his name for another awards run.
What’s Next
Netflix is giving the sequel a two-week exclusive run in IMAX theaters starting November 25, 2026, a rare big-screen push for the streamer. It then arrives on Netflix worldwide on December 23, 2026, putting it right in the middle of the holiday viewing season and the awards conversation. Full reviews should follow in the coming days and will show whether the early enthusiasm holds.
Sources
- Variety – ‘Cliff Booth’ First Reactions
- SlashFilm – Brad Pitt’s Cliff Booth movie reactions
- CinemaBlend – Reactions to Brad Pitt’s new Cliff Booth movie
- The Hollywood Reporter – First Reactions
